Association of Police and Crime Commissioners

PCC candidates and candidate surveys 2012


Welcome to our archive for the first ever PCC election which took place on the 15th November 2012.

Summary of results

Winners:             

16 Conservative (39% of 41)

13 Labour (31.7%)

12 Independent (29.2%)

Overall vote share:

33% Labour

27% Conservative

22% Independent (Independents did not contest seven seats)

 

PCC Election Results 2012 (in order of declaration time)
Results Declared: 41            
British Freedom Party 0 Green Party 0   Labour Party
Northumbria
Merseyside
Cleveland
Durham
South Yorkshire
West Midlands
Bedfordshire
Lancashire
Greater Manchester
South Wales
Derbyshire
Nottinghamshire
West Yorkshire
13
Conservative Party
Wiltshire
Dyfed Powys
North Yorkshire
Leicestershire
Hertfordshire
Essex
Suffolk
Cumbria
Thames Valley
Staffordshire
Sussex
Northamptonshire
Humberside
Cambridgeshire
Cheshire
Devon & Cornwall


16 Independent
Dorset
North Wales
Gwent
Warwickshire
Gloucestershire
West Mercia
Hampshire
Kent
Surrey
Avon & Somerset
Lincolnshire
Norfolk
12 Liberal Democrats
English Democrats 0 JAC Party 0 UKIP 0
Yet to Declare: 0            

You can download a list of PCC candidates who stood for election here.

2012 PCC candidates' statements can be found at www.choosemypcc.org.uk

Analysis of PCC candidates' priorities

The APCC conducted a thorough trawl of the websites and online statements of Police and Crime Commissioner candidates to provide a summary of their most commonly-cited areas of concern. We counted the number of times specific issues were mentioned and whilst retaining separate tallies for each mention, have grouped together similar issues for ease of reference.


The full analysis of candidates' most-cited concerns is here.

A 'wordle' (pictogram) of the results is also available here.

Summary of nominations:

Background: our research and analysis of candidates' own election addresses showed that of the total of 192 candidates running across 41 police areas;

  • 99 (51.56%) are or have been elected politicians (councillors, MPs, MEPs, Assembly Members or a combination thereof)
  • Over 50% have experience of working in the fields of policing or criminal justice
    39 (20.3%) are known to have served on a police authority
  • 32 (16.6%) are known to have been employed by or served within the police service (predominantly former officers but also some Special Constables)
  • 26 (13.5%) have experience of work within the criminal justice sector, but outside of the police service
  • 16 (8.3%) are known to have served in the armed forces
  • 16 (8.3%) are known to be, or have been a Magistrate
  • 35 (18%) of candidates are women 
Party affiliations: there were
  • Labour and the Conservatives candidates in every area (the Labour candidate in Northamptonshire withdrew after the relevant deadline so therefore remained on the ballot paper)
  • 54 (28%) Independent candidates (34, or all but 7 areas have at least one Independent candidate; there are 6 running in Devon and Cornwall)
  • 24 Liberal Democrat candidates
  • 24 UKIP candidates
  • 5 English Democrat candidates
Also standing:
  • One Green Party candidate (Cleveland)
  • One Justice and Anti-Corruption Party candidate (Hampshire)
  • One British Freedom Party candidate (Bedfordshire)


Our summary of when the counts started, when results were expected and when PCCs might be asked to declare their acceptance of office (the 'PCC Oath') ordered by expected time of declaration is here.

Avon and Somerset
Official result breakdown
Elected: Sue Mountstevens

Pete Levy - Liberal Democrat
Ken Maddock - Conservative
Sue Mountstevens - Independent
Dr John Savage - Labour

Bedfordshire
Official result breakdown
Elected:
Oliver Martins

Kevin Carroll - British Freedom Party
Linda Jack - Liberal Democrat
Oliver Martins - Labour
Jasbir Parmar - Conservative
Rashid Mezanur - Independent

Cambridgeshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Sir Graham Bright

Ansar Ali - Independent
Sir Graham Bright - Conservative
Paul Bullen - UKIP
Stephen Goldspink - English Democrats
Farooq Mohammed - Independent
Rupert Moss-Eccardt - Liberal Democrat
Ed Murphy - Labour

Cheshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: John Dwyer

Ainsley Arnold - Liberal Democrat
Louise Bours - UKIP
John Dwyer - Conservative
Sarah Flannery - Independent
John Stockton - Labour

Cleveland
Official result breakdown
Elected: Barry Coppinger

Sultan Alam - Independent
Barry Coppinger - Labour
Ken Lupton - Conservative
Joe Michna - Green Party

Cumbria
Official result breakdown
Elected: Richard Rhodes

Pru Jupe - Liberal Democrat
Patrick Leonard - Labour
Richard Rhodes - Conservative
Mary Robinson - Independent

Derbyshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Alan Charles

Alan Charles - Labour
David Gale - UKIP
Rod Hutton - Independent
Simon Spencer - Conservative

Devon and Cornwall
Official result breakdown
Elected: Commodore Tony Hogg

Brian Blake - Liberal Democrat
Graham Calderwood - Independent
Brian Greenslade - Independent
Commodore Tony Hogg - Conservative
Ivan Jordan - Independent
Tam McPherson - Independent
William Morris - Independent
John Smith - Independent
Robert Smith - UKIP
Nicky Williams - Labour

Dorset
Official result breakdown
Elected: Martyn Underhill

Andrew Canning- Liberal Democrat
Nick King - Conservative
Rachel Rogers - Labour
Martyn Underhill - Independent

Durham
Official result breakdown
Elected: Ron Hogg

Mike Costello - UKIP
Ron Hogg - Labour
Kingsley Smith - Independent
Nick Varley - Conservative

Dyfed-Powys
Official result breakdown
Elected: Christopher Salmon

Christine Gwyther - Labour
Christopher Salmon - Conservative

Essex
Official result breakdown
Elected: Nick Alston

Nicholas Alston - Conservative  
Linda Belgrove - Independent
Val Morris-Cook - Labour
Andrew Smith - UKIP
Mick Thwaites - Independent
Robin Tilbrook - English Democrat

Gloucestershire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Martin Surl

Victoria Atkins - Conservative
Alistair Cameron - Liberal Democrat
Rupi Dhanda - Labour
Martin Surl - Independent

Greater Manchester
Official result breakdown
Elected: Tony Lloyd

Matthew Gallagher - Liberal Democrat
Tony Lloyd - Labour
Roy Warren - Independent
Michael Winstanley - Conservative
Steven Woolfe - UKIP 

Gwent
Official result breakdown
Elected: Ian Johnston

Ian Johnston - Independent
Hamish Sandison - Labour
Nick Webb - Conservative
Chris Wright - Independent

Hampshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Simon Hayes

David Goodall - Liberal Democrat
Simon Hayes - Independent
Don Jerrard - Justice & Anti-Corruption Party
Michael Mates - Conservative
Stephen West - UKIP
Jacqui Rayment - Labour

Hertfordshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: David Lloyd

Sherma Batson - Labour
David Lloyd - Conservative
Marion Mason - UKIP
Christopher Townsend - Liberal Democrat 

Humberside
Official result breakdown
Elected: Matthew Grove

Godfrey Bloom - UKIP
Simone Butterworth- Liberal Democrat
Paul Davison - Independent
Neil Eyre - Independent
Matthew Grove - Conservative
John Prescott - Labour
Walter Sweeney - Independent

Kent
Official result breakdown
Elected: Ann Barnes

Ann Barnes - Independent
Dai Liyanage - Independent
Craig Mackinlay - Conservative
Steve Uncles - English Democrat
Piers Wauchope - UKIP
Harriet Yeo - Labour

Lancashire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Clive Grunshaw

Afzal Anwar - Liberal Democrat
Tim Ashton - Conservative
Robert Drobny - UKIP
Clive Grunshaw- Labour

Leicestershire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Sir Clive Loader

Air Chief Marshall Sir Clive Loader - Conservative
Suleman Nagdi - Independent
Sarah Russell - Labour

Lincolnshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Alan Hardwick 

David Bowles - Independent
Richard Davies - Conservative
Paul Gleeson- Labour
Alan Hardwick - Independent

Merseyside
Official result breakdown
Elected: Jane Kennedy
Geoff Gubb - Conservative
Hilary Jones - UKIP
Paula Keaveney - Liberal Democrat
Jane Kennedy - Labour
Kiron Reid - Independent
Paul Rimmer - English Democrat

Norfolk
Official result breakdown
Elected: Stephen Bett
Jamie Athill - Conservative 
Stephen Bett - Independent
James Joyce - Liberal Democrat
Steve Morphew - Labour
Matthew Smith - UKIP

Northamptonshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Adam Simmonds
Lee Barron - Labour (withdrawn but on the ballot)
Jim MacArthur - UKIP
John Norrie - Independent
Adam Simmonds - Conservative
Paul Varnsverry - Liberal Democrat

Northumbria
Official result breakdown
Elected: Vera Baird
Dr Peter Andras - Liberal Democrat
Vera Baird - Labour
Philip Butler - Conservative
Alistair Baxter - UKIP

North Yorkshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Julia Mulligan
Julia Mulligan - Conservative
Ruth Potter - Labour

North Wales
Official result breakdown
Elected: Winston Roddick
Richard Hibbs - Independent
Colm McCabe - Conservative
Tal Michael - Labour
Warwick Nicholson - UKIP
Winston Roddick - Independent

Nottinghamshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Paddy Tipping
Dr Raj Chandran - Independent
Tony Roberts - Conservative
Malcolm Spencer - Independent
Paddy Tipping - Labour

South Wales
Official result breakdown
Elected: Alun Michael
Mike Baker - Independent
Caroline Jones - Conservative
Alun Michael - Labour
Antonio Verdame - Independent

South Yorkshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Shaun Wright

David Allen - English Democrat
Jonathan Arnott - UKIP
Nigel Bonson - Conservative
Robert Teal - Liberal Democrat
Shaun Wright - Labour

Staffordshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Matthew Ellis
Matthew Ellis - Conservative
Joy Garner - Labour

Suffolk
Official result breakdown
Elected: Tim Passmore
David Cocks - Independent
Jane Basham - Labour
Bill Mountford - UKIP
Tim Passmore - Conservative

Surrey
Official result breakdown
Elected: Kevin Hurley
Robert Evans - Labour
Kevin Hurley - Independent
Julie Iles - Conservative
Nick O’Shea - Liberal Democrat
Robert Shatwell - UKIP
Peter Williams - Independent

Sussex
Official result breakdown
Elected: Katy Bourne
Tony Armstrong - UKIP
Katy Bourne - Conservative
Ian Chisnall - Independent
Godfrey Daniel - Labour
David Rogers - Liberal Democrat

Thames Valley
Official result breakdown
Elected: Anthony Stansfeld
Patience Tayo Awe - Independent
Barry Cooper - UKIP
Geoff Howard - Independent
Professor John Howson - Liberal Democrat
Anthony Stansfeld - Conservative 
Tim Starkey - Labour

Warwickshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Ron Ball
Ron Ball - Independent
Fraser Pithie - Conservative
James Plaskitt - Labour

West Mercia
Official result breakdown
Elected: Bill Longmore
Adrian Blackshaw - Conservative
Bill Longmore - Independent
Simon Murphy - Labour

West Midlands
Official result breakdown
Elected: Bob Jones
Matt Bennett - Conservative
Bill Etheridge - UKIP
Cath Hannon - Independent
Bob Jones - Labour
Ayoub Khan - Liberal Democrat
Mike Rumble - Independent
Bishop Derek Webley - Independent

West Yorkshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Mark Burns-Williamson
Mark Burns-Williamson - Labour
Geraldine Carter - Conservative
Cedric Christie - Independent
Andrew Marchington - Liberal Democrat

Wiltshire
Official result breakdown
Elected: Angus Macpherson - Conservative

Paul Batchelor - Liberal Democrat
Angus Macpherson - Conservative
Clare Moody - Labour
John Short - UKIP
Liam Silcocks - Independent
Colin Skelton - Independent